|
| Time For a Boycott? | |
|
+28Richard Blight 125+1 Jethro Rollo Tomasi GreenSam Czarcasm Elias VillageGreen zyph PatDunne Greenlander Dougie AstiSpumante Sir Francis Drake green_genie Cornish Rebel Les Miserable pepsipete argyl3 mouldyoldgoat Tringreen tigertony akagreengull pilgrimfather Lord Melbury Greenskin Hitch sufferedsince 68 32 posters | |
Author | Message |
---|
Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:00 pm | |
| - Sir Francis Drake wrote:
- I think the last Hodges XI started at Torquay on November 14th 2000 (as memory suggests) and Greens On Screen gives this line-up:
John Hodges, Paul Wotton, Jon Beswetherick, Chris Leadbitter, Steve Adams, Craig Taylor, Martin Phillips, Martin Barlow, Sean McCarthy, Paul McGregor, Lee Phillips. Subs: Steve Guinan, Jason Peake, Kevin Wills.
The most recent Sheridan line-up was:
McCormick, Nelson, McHugh, Hartley, Mellor, Lee (Cox 70), Bobby Reid, O'Connor, Talbot, Alessandra, Reuben Reid (Brunt 89). Non-playing subs: Bittner, Purrington, Norburn, Flanagan.
I'd say the best XI from those two is:
McCormick, Mellor, Beswetherick, Taylor, Nelson, Hartley, O'Connor, Ledbitter, Phillips, RReid, McGregor.
So that's 6-5 in favour of Sheridan's mob.
Not exactly conclusive that either squad is better but more suggestive that they are much the same. Adam Barrett and Chris Hargreaves were pretty decent in that side as well. The notion that This squad would wipe the floor with the Hodges squad is pure unequivocal nonsense. And i'm not trying to big up the Hodges era either, merely pointing out that Brent has delivered a squad no better then Mad Dan's and yet is enjoying an easy ride.
Last edited by Punchdrunk on Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:01 pm; edited 1 time in total |
| | | VillageGreen
Posts : 6103 Join date : 2012-01-13 Age : 60 Location : Plymouth
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:00 pm | |
| - Punchdrunk wrote:
- [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
God give me strength. I know the chap who is in photo seven. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:03 pm | |
| - Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it. - zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from. Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals. Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever?
Last edited by ejh on Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:07 pm; edited 2 times in total |
| | | zyph
Posts : 13369 Join date : 2014-03-02 Age : 85
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:04 pm | |
| ......and I know four of the people in photo six........anymore bids. |
| | | zyph
Posts : 13369 Join date : 2014-03-02 Age : 85
| | | | VillageGreen
Posts : 6103 Join date : 2012-01-13 Age : 60 Location : Plymouth
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:09 pm | |
| - zyph wrote:
- ......and I know four of the people in photo six........anymore bids.
The chap i know in photo seven was on tv, that game show with Anne Robinson. I believe he got to the final and won money. He is a good lad. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:12 pm | |
| - ejh wrote:
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? Most of the Hodges squad also plied their careers at a higher level at some point in their careers just like many players do at other clubs. Parsons....Crap Banton....Crap Blizzard...Crap McHugh....Dodgy Morgan...uber Crap Norburn...Average Lee.....Average Hayes...Coudnt hit a barn door with a banjo when he was at Argyle Flanagan....Dodgy |
| | | sufferedsince 68
Posts : 6420 Join date : 2014-06-01 Location : Brentocabin
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:16 pm | |
| - ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? How come your hero's squad of top drawer winners struggled to beat Accy Stan for their first win in eight? with a couple of exceptions they joined Mid table non ambitious Argyle, because other clubs were not interested! they are fourth division journeymen thats all. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:25 pm | |
| We will see at the end of the season eh !? Here on ATD the 'good guys' have a knack of being proved right |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:33 pm | |
| - ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. |
| | | PatDunne
Posts : 2614 Join date : 2013-11-21 Age : 63
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 6:34 pm | |
| Can the Trust ask why Brent is signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever at the next meeting?, and pasties - always good to ask a question about pasties. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:16 pm | |
| - Graiser wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. Using logic you could also ask the question why these players aren't playing in the CCC or League 1 now? The answer to that is that they arent deemed good enough by their parent clubs to play in that division. If we had bought those players from those divisions when they were playing every game and scoring goals we wouldn't be where we are now. The table speaks for itself, 1 win in 8 is it? |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:20 pm | |
| who is "chippy"? Bored of argyle 'celebrities'. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:31 pm | |
| Anyway applying your logic of rating our squad Craig Noone would have been the Robert conference north or something, shorely not the right pedigree for a Brent side? |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:35 pm | |
| - Graiser wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. 7 got to get your little dig in havent you lol |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:41 pm | |
| - Punchdrunk wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? Most of the Hodges squad also plied their careers at a higher level at some point in their careers just like many players do at other clubs.
Parsons....Crap Banton....Crap Blizzard...Crap McHugh....Dodgy Morgan...uber Crap Norburn...Average Lee.....Average Hayes...Coudnt hit a barn door with a banjo when he was at Argyle Flanagan....Dodgy
These players had good reputations and were proven at higher levels than League Two. If only Sheridan and Brent had as much wisdom as you have when we signed these players. We might not have paid them so much, or signed them at all. You could have advised them to show some real ambition and sign the next Paul Gibbs. |
| | | Sir Francis Drake
Posts : 7461 Join date : 2011-12-03 Age : 33 Location : Nr Panama
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:49 pm | |
| - Iggy wrote:
- Graiser wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. Using logic you could also ask the question why these players aren't playing in the CCC or League 1 now? The answer to that is that they arent deemed good enough by their parent clubs to play in that division. If we had bought those players from those divisions when they were playing every game and scoring goals we wouldn't be where we are now. The table speaks for itself, 1 win in 8 is it? I can see both sides of the argument so maybe the data is good but the wrong hypothesis is being tested? As an alternative why not consider what happened to them post-Argyle? This chops the outcomes down significantly becase most of them are still here but: Matt Parsons: I don't know but probably still injured Marvin Morgan: Hartlepoole L2 Caolan Lavery: Chesterfield L1 (unsure about this) Andy Kellett: Man Utd (that still sounds amazing, doesn't it!) Paul Hayes: Wycombe L2 So 2 on the way up (Lavery and Kellett) and 2 stagnators (Morgan and Hayes). Matt Parsons is the tie-breaker here but whatever he's doing any conclusions are of dubious worth given no clear pattern. Ultimately it is League position that counts and we're 8th: better than we have been and not as good as I feel it should be. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:49 pm | |
| matt parsons is currently playing non league football for maidenhead. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:52 pm | |
| - Angry wrote:
- matt parsons is currently playing non league football for maidenhead.
I rest my case [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:56 pm | |
| - Iggy wrote:
- Anyway applying your logic of rating our squad Craig Noone would have been the Robert conference north or something, shorely not the right pedigree for a Brent side?
I am simply saying that these aren't cheap mediocre 'journeymen', as some of you insist on saying. All of our signings have been under 30 years of age, and with the exception of 3, come from clubs higher than us in the pyramid, for the most part higher tiers. Yet some of you with the anti Brent agenda will not accept that he delivers decent quality players for Sheridan relative to our position. In fact you argue the players are average and crap. McCormick, Hartley, McHugh, Nelson, Mellor, Cox, O'Connor and Reuben Reid are League One quality players in my opinion. It is only a mixture of Sheridan's failings as a manager, a bit of bad luck with injuries, and disputes over loan extensions that have stopped this side being where it deserves to be - which is around 3rd to 5th in my opinion. Hopefully there is time enough yet to rebuild the momentum necessary to get our snouts in the playoffs. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 7:58 pm | |
| - sufferedsince 68 wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League On Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? How come your hero's squad of top drawer winners struggled to beat Accy Stan for their first win in eight? with a couple of exceptions they joined Mid table non ambitious Argyle, because other clubs were not interested! they are fourth division journeymen thats all. I expect some Chelsea supporters were asking the same question when Bradford beat them in their own back yard, not quite as simple as that is it ? |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 8:02 pm | |
| - ejh wrote:
- Iggy wrote:
- Anyway applying your logic of rating our squad Craig Noone would have been the Robert conference north or something, shorely not the right pedigree for a Brent side?
I am simply saying that these aren't cheap mediocre 'journeymen', as some of you insist on saying.
All of our signings have been under 30 years of age, and with the exception of 3, come from clubs higher than us in the pyramid, for the most part higher tiers.
Yet some of you with the anti Brent agenda will not accept that he delivers decent quality players for Sheridan relative to our position. In fact you argue the players are average and crap.
McCormick, Hartley, McHugh, Nelson, Mellor, Cox, O'Connor and Reuben Reid are League One quality players in my opinion. It is only a mixture of Sheridan's failings as a manager, a bit of bad luck with injuries, and disputes over loan extensions that have stopped this side being where it deserves to be - which is around 3rd to 5th in my opinion.
Hopefully there is time enough yet to rebuild the momentum necessary to get our snouts in the playoffs. There are none so blind as those who refuse to see. And if we get into the play-offs I will eat my hat. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 8:04 pm | |
| - Sir Francis Drake wrote:
- Iggy wrote:
- Graiser wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League One Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. Using logic you could also ask the question why these players aren't playing in the CCC or League 1 now? The answer to that is that they arent deemed good enough by their parent clubs to play in that division. If we had bought those players from those divisions when they were playing every game and scoring goals we wouldn't be where we are now. The table speaks for itself, 1 win in 8 is it? I can see both sides of the argument so maybe the data is good but the wrong hypothesis is being tested?
As an alternative why not consider what happened to them post-Argyle?
This chops the outcomes down significantly becase most of them are still here but:
Matt Parsons: I don't know but probably still injured Marvin Morgan: Hartlepoole L2 Caolan Lavery: Chesterfield L1 (unsure about this) Andy Kellett: Man Utd (that still sounds amazing, doesn't it!) Paul Hayes: Wycombe L2
So 2 on the way up (Lavery and Kellett) and 2 stagnators (Morgan and Hayes). Matt Parsons is the tie-breaker here but whatever he's doing any conclusions are of dubious worth given no clear pattern.
Ultimately it is League position that counts and we're 8th: better than we have been and not as good as I feel it should be. Wouldn't really regard Hayes as stagnating. His position as the main striker for the division's league leaders is somewhat better than Argyle's fortunes right now, which is 'fingers crossed for the playoffs'. Although I imagine that will be Brent's fault he didn't score in the 5 or 6 games he was here. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 8:05 pm | |
| - Angry wrote:
- Graiser wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League Onei Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. 7
got to get your little dig in havent you lol As we all are, I'd call it an opinion, that's what a fans forum is about isn't it ? |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? Sun Feb 08, 2015 8:10 pm | |
| - Graiser wrote:
- Angry wrote:
- Graiser wrote:
- ejh wrote:
- Punchdrunk wrote:
- They are what they are,mediocre league 2 players with a mediocre league 2 manager, and what do you get ?
A mediocre league 2 side that sits between mid table and the play off's..no shit Sherlock.
And this team is head and shoulders above Kevin Hodges/ Macauleys Argyle ejh ?! My arse is it.
- zyph wrote:
- This squad is adequate for Div 2......and when they are playing well have proved that they could get us out of this division.......life in Div 1 is a different kettle of fish, needing new players to strengthen the squad......we have to live post-administration and do it with minimum funds.....keeping to the repayment of that debt.....which the FL oversee.
Matt Parsons: Premier League Jason Banton: Premier League Anthony O'Connor: Championship Reuben Reid: Championship/League One Dominic Blizzard: Championship/League One Peter Hartley: League One Carl McHugh: League One Lee Cox: League One Marvin Morgan: League One Kelvin Mellor: League Onei Lewis Alessandra: League Two Luke McCormick: League Two Ollie Norburn: League Two/Conference Ryan Brunt: Conference
The above is a list of the permanent signings Sheridan has made while at the club, followed by either the previous standard of football they were playing, or the tier of the club we signed the player from.
Here is the same with Sheridan's loan deals.
Caolan Lavery: Championship Andy Kellett: Championship Olly Lee: Championship Bobby Reid: League One Paul Hayes: League One Drew Talbot: League One Tom Flanagan: League One
To say we have an average midtable League Two quality squad as another stick to beat Brent with is pure nonsense and totally ignores the facts. It is getting to the point where you must have to suspend reality to believe that James Brent is actively signing crap players to save money and keep Argyle shit forever? EJH I think you present a logical debate, I doubt most others would see it that way as it doesn't match their agenda. There's no doubt Sheridans has brought some good quality players to this club, a couple of failures as well, but hey even the best premier managers buy some duck eggs. As to whether Sheridan brings out the best in them well that's open for discussion and come May if we don't get promotion he'll be gone anyway. 7
got to get your little dig in havent you lol As we all are, I'd call it an opinion, that's what a fans forum is about isn't it ?
who said anything about your opinion, im commentating on your inability to post without a dig at this place first. |
| | | Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Time For a Boycott? | |
| |
| | | | Time For a Boycott? | |
|
Similar topics | |
|
| Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |