Opinion of Sheridan's signings so far?

To early to tell but your verdict on our new players?

Guy Branstone: Looks solid to me, very good head on him, perhaps needs to work on his positioning however he certainly forms a good partnership with Nelson.

Anthony Charles: Certainly not a full back, looked uncomfy today and always looked to get in to the middle. I think he would be a good CB but for now, williams needs to return to LB. Poor debut.

Ronan Murray: Looked good in his first game, he has some quality on the ball however his lack of effort annoys me, he seems to drift in and out of games an awful lot, more of an impact player.

Ugwu: Not yet played.

Reid: Looked our only threat today. I think he's strong, he certainly doesn't give up on a loose ball and looks to get himself in to good positions, will score goals i think.

Branston- dodgy with the ball. Positioning hot and cold. Often I feel that the other three defenders are more like where he ought to be rather than him being the one in the wrong. Generally very good and has tightened up our defence hugely.

Charles-yep, not a full-back. Dire first half but improved second to be fair to him. Maybe would be better at CB.

Murray-good in parts, crossing is better than anyone else who has played for us this season. Positioning questionable, drifts in and out of games and seems to run out of steam too often. I think he'd be better out wide. Promise is there.

Uwgu=N/A

Reid-looked average today I thought. Good in flashes but never really got into the game. Positionally poor and not alert enough over 90 minutes.

If I'm not mistaken they're all loan signings?. We'll do well to see the best of any of them given their respective time-frames. So far Murray has had 2 different partners up front, not easy for him. The same reasoning could be applied to all of them.

You also have to consider who's playing around them. Players with a losing mentality whom the majority will no doubt be booted out this summer.

Wow, the power of the t'internet.

A synopsis of Sheridan's signings (although as Coxy rightly points out loan signings and emergency loan signings at that) yet the man has been in charge of two games.

Make no mistake this club was heading for the BSP.

For anyone to turn this around requires a dozen games. Unfortuntaly JS is going to have to blood and snotters a few on his way. 2 games, 3 points and one clean sheet. This is all about surviving and that's a start. Brent is to blame for this mess and no-one else.

are we really judging players after 2 and in some cases 1 game for the club?

We can judge them on their performance so far, why not? Opinions can be changed, it's nice to hear some football talked about to be honest.

Big Robbie has nothing to worry about, Anthony Charles was pretty useless, the other three have been pretty hit and miss so far..

Iggy wrote:

We can judge them on their performance so far, why not? Opinions can be changed, it's nice to hear some football talked about to be honest.

i think its far crass too and sparks of desperation to undermine why not do it when they have played about 5 games before saying they are good/bad.

We'll do well to be able to judge our loanees after 5 games, assuming some don't feck off back home or simply warm the subs bench because we can't afford to pay them (good one Webby). Any other club would be in crisis, we'll just do the motions on our way to oblivion.

My opinion is they have all been dissappointing but early days.The only one that looks useless is Murray who looks as if he has never played trhe game before and never wants to again.

Thought Murray was MOM V Morecambe, perhaps he can only play in the rain!

My opinion on Sheridan's signings?

Couldn't give a flying one. Very little about this football club interests me anymore.

Tis early doors as they say. I am just hoping that they all gel rather quickly and keep Argyle in the Football League.

If not,then it won't be pretty.....

Angry of Mayfair wrote:

are we really judging players after 2 and in some cases 1 game for the club?

looks like we are.

I would like to edit my view on Murray: ABSOLUTELY USELESS

i would say hes struggling to get anyone decent down here, some dimwit spent the money it seems...................

Murray is appalling. Just a staggeringly lazy attitude and not what we need.

any chance village green's avatar can be resized?

Branston- good signing, better than Purse

Charles- poor/ average defender but can't pass and panics too easily

Murray- Looked good in flashes against Morecombe, shit otherwise

Reid- Looks very rusty in front of goal but shows good strength holding the ball up

Banton- great first half on saturday (take note about the final ball PCH!) and could provide ammo for a decent striker

Ugwu- Injured

PlymptonPilgrim wrote:

My opinion on Sheridan's signings?

Couldn't give a flying one. Very little about this football club interests me anymore.

So why are you on an Argyle forum then!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

125+1 wrote:

PlymptonPilgrim wrote:

My opinion on Sheridan's signings?

Couldn't give a flying one. Very little about this football club interests me anymore.

So why are you on an Argyle forum then!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hell yeh Garry,yooom naaaaaat a praaaaaaaaaperrrrr faaaaaaaan!

Greenskin wrote:

125+1 wrote:

PlymptonPilgrim wrote:

My opinion on Sheridan's signings?

Couldn't give a flying one. Very little about this football club interests me anymore.

So why are you on an Argyle forum then!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hell yeh Garry,yooom naaaaaat a praaaaaaaaaperrrrr faaaaaaaan!

Angry of Mayfair wrote:

any chance village green's avatar can be resized?

Changed the avatar now.....

If ever there was a poisoned chalice then Sheridan has now got it!

The fact we're relying on so many loan signings is significant, there's zero ambition beyond this season. This club ought to be demonstrating intent and not merely survival. Even the manager has only until the end of the season, can Brent feck off too please?