Greatest Pilgrims

Guest

Anyone else keeping an eye on this?

i dont disagree much with the winners atm but its more the placings of the others that im baffled by here they are in full cause some have issues clicking links.

Greatest Centre-Back Results So Far
1. Graham Coughlan
2. Paul Wotton
3. Krisztian Timar
4. Sonny Bradley
5. Jack Chisholm
6. Mick Heathcote
7. Marcel Seip
8. Curtis Nelson
9. Nicky Marker
10. Gerry McElhinney
11. Mark Smith
12. Mike Green
13. John Newman
14. Hasney Aljofree
15. Chris Harrison
16. John Williams
17. Bobby Saxton
18. Mathias Doumbe
19. Andy Morrison
20. Kari Arnason
21.Peter Hartley
22. Adam Barrett
23. Darren Purse
24. Forbes Phillipson-Masters
25. Neil Hague

Greatest Full-Back Results
1. Paul Connolly
2. Gordon Nisbet
3. Tony Capaldi
4. Gary Sawyer
5. Mark Patterson
6. David Worrell
7. Paul Williams
8. Gary Poole
9. Colin Sullivan
10. Peter Gilbert
11. Moses Russell
12. Onismor Bhasera
13. Leigh Cooper
14. John Hore
15. Marc Edworthy
16. Lee Hodges
17. Brian McGlinchey
18. Dave Provan
19. Phil Burrows
20. Jon Beswetherick
21. John Uzzell
22. Tony Book
23. Septimus Atterbury
24. Pat Jones
25. Wayne O’Sullivan

Greatest Goalkeeper Results
1. Romain Larrieu
2. Luke McCormick
3. Jim Furnell
4. Alan Nicholls
5. Geoff Crudgington
6. Bill Shortt
7. Alan Miller
8. Steve Cherry
9. Peter Shilton
10. Rhys Wilmot
11. Dave MacLaren
12. Fred Craig
13. Pat Dunne
14. Remi Matthews
15. Milija Aleksic
16. Jon Sheffield
17. Paul Barron
18. Martin Hodge
19. Bruce Grobbelaar
20. Geoff Barnsley
21. Harry Cann
22. John Willie Sutcliffe
23. David Stockdale
24. Bill Harper
25. Neil Ramsbottom

Subject: Re: Greatest Pilgrims Thu Jul 04, 2019 6:07 am

Greatest Centre back definately Nicky Marker
Greatest full back Brian Bason (how the hell did he get missed from the list lol)
Greatest keeper has to be Martin Hodge be hard to include Shilton

Thats only me picking from the lists having seen those players

Subject: Re: Greatest Pilgrims Thu Jul 04, 2019 9:02 am

But it depends when you was a fan from.
So only being a fan since 98/99.

I'd have to go for players since then

Subject: Re: Greatest Pilgrims Thu Jul 04, 2019 9:30 am

Capaldi never played fullback for us, did he?

Posts : 12371 Join date : 2017-09-09

Most annoying left back ever innit?

Subject: Re: Greatest Pilgrims Thu Jul 04, 2019 10:28 am

No Gary Miller!!!!!! or ATD's Robbie William's?????

Fookin' fumin'

Guest

Mock Cuncher wrote:: Capaldi never played fullback for us, did he?

He was played at Left back under Ollie

Posts : 12371 Join date : 2017-09-09

He was a great dead ball player, made a sweet cross and his runs we're pretty good but I don't think I once saw him stick his foot in and make a tackle, do the old jazz hands shuffle facing the attacking threat, back off a little, back off a little, then watch mutely as the cross we could all see coming sails over his shoulder into our penalty box. Defender he deffo was not.

Guest

Timar number 3 makes me laugh considering he only had one good season. Jon Beswetherick is my worst left back of all time clueless at best and Hasney Aljofree good backup defender but not sure id list him that high in the top 25.

Posts : 7516 Join date : 2014-03-30

Aviva to the core. jocolor

Posts : 12371 Join date : 2017-09-09

Angry wrote:: Timar number 3 makes me laugh considering he only had one good season. Jon Beswetherick is my worst left back of all time clueless at best and Hasney Aljofree good backup defender but not sure id list him that high in the top 25.

What completely skews these kind of polls is the age of the person deciding. If you started following Argyle in zollies time then Timar should make the top three. Not only a great defender he played some pin point passes across and up the pitch for Halmosi to dispose of and he was great at corners and free kick headers.
If you started to follow in Brent's day then you've only got the last seven years and they weren't great.

Posts : 12371 Join date : 2017-09-09

Shelley deserves his place he was a very underrated player here at times.

Posts : 12371 Join date : 2017-09-09

And no Steve Adams despite Luggy voting for him on repeat.

Guest

Greatest Winger Results
1. Peter Halmosi
2. David Norris
3. Graham Carey
4. Kevin Hodges
5. Paul Dalton
6. Jack Leslie
7. Martin Phillips
8. Garry Nelson
9. Gordon Astall
10. Martin Barlow
11. Ruben Lameiras
12. Barrie Jones
13. Hugh McAuley
14. Scott Sinclair
15. Alex Govan
16. Craig Noone
17. David Phillips
18. Nicky Jennings
19. Peter Anderson
20. Brian Johnson
21. Billy Strauss
22. Neil Dougall
23. Yannick Bolasie
24. Mike Trebilcock
25. Jake Jervis

Halmosi wins

Subject: Re: Greatest Pilgrims Sun Jul 07, 2019 4:47 pm

I bet that most of the voters never heard or saw Barrie Jones or Nicky Jennings wonderful players leave the other standing

Guest

Tgwu wrote:: I bet that most of the voters never heard or saw Barrie Jones or Nicky Jennings wonderful players leave the other standing

it does strike me that alot of those who voted in this started supporting the club from 02 onwards.

Subject: Re: Greatest Pilgrims Sun Jul 07, 2019 4:54 pm

Of those wingers personally would have gone with Paul Dalton

Guest

Nicky Jennings was the best winger for me, he was mesmerising

Guest

Earwegoagain wrote:: And no Steve Adams despite Luggy voting for him on repeat.

Voted 12th greatest midfielder

i laughed when i saw that seeing the players who where ranked lower than him the whole greatest pilgrim thing is a joke lol.

results so far

6. Johnny Williams
7. Kevin Summerfield
8. Ronnie Mauge
9. John Matthews
10. Chris Billy
11. Norman Piper
12. Steve Adams
13. Andy Thomas
14. Carl Fletcher
15. Ernie Machin
16. Dan Gosling
17. David Fox
18. John Delve
19. Gary Megson
20. Chris Hargreaves
21. Conor Hourihane
22. Russell Coughlin
23. Chris Leadbitter
24. Andy Rogers
25. David Burnside

Guest

Angry wrote:

Earwegoagain wrote:: And no Steve Adams despite Luggy voting for him on repeat.

Voted 12th greatest midfielder

i laughed when i saw that seeing the players who where ranked lower than him the whole greatest pilgrim thing is a joke lol.

results so far
1. David Friio
2. Lilian Nalis
3. Akos Buzsaky
4. Steve McCall
5. Steve Castle
6. Johnny Williams
7. Kevin Summerfield
8. Ronnie Mauge
9. John Matthews
10. Chris Billy
11. Norman Piper
12. Steve Adams
13. Andy Thomas
14. Carl Fletcher
15. Ernie Machin
16. Dan Gosling
17. David Fox
18. John Delve
19. Gary Megson
20. Chris Hargreaves
21. Conor Hourihane
22. Russell Coughlin
23. Chris Leadbitter
24. Andy Rogers
25. David Burnside

updated the list David Friio le god won afro

Guest

Greatest Striker Results So Far
6. Billy Rafferty
7. David Kemp
8. Reuben Reid
9. Dwight Marshall
10. Bradley Wright-Phillips
11. Wilf Carter
12. Ian Stonebridge
13. Barry Hayles
14. Maurice Tadman
15. Marino Keith
16. Jack Cock
17. Jamie Mackie
18. Gordon Staniforth
19. Carlo Corazzin
20. Fred Binney
21. Adrian Littlejohn
22. Steve Cooper
23. Paul Gallagher
24. Paul McGregor
25. Derek Rickard

Im going to guess that the final 5 will go like this

1. Tommy Tynan
2. Paul Mariner
3. Mickey Evans
4. Nathan Lowndes Wink

5. Freddie Ladapo

Posts : 12371 Join date : 2017-09-09

Angry wrote:

Earwegoagain wrote:: And no Steve Adams despite Luggy voting for him on repeat.

Voted 12th greatest midfielder

i laughed when i saw that seeing the players who where ranked lower than him the whole greatest pilgrim thing is a joke lol.

results so far
1. David Friio
2. Lilian Nalis
3. Akos Buzsaky
4. Steve McCall
5. Steve Castle
6. Johnny Williams
7. Kevin Summerfield
8. Ronnie Mauge
9. John Matthews
10. Chris Billy
11. Norman Piper
12. Steve Adams
13. Andy Thomas
14. Carl Fletcher
15. Ernie Machin
16. Dan Gosling
17. David Fox
18. John Delve
19. Gary Megson
20. Chris Hargreaves
21. Conor Hourihane
22. Russell Coughlin
23. Chris Leadbitter
24. Andy Rogers
25. David Burnside

updated the list David Friio le god won afro

Lol Adams above Hourihane, Gosling, Hargreaves, Megson, Coughlin.

Posts : 7516 Join date : 2014-03-30

Angry wrote:: Greatest Striker Results So Far
6. Billy Rafferty
7. David Kemp
8. Reuben Reid
9. Dwight Marshall
10. Bradley Wright-Phillips
11. Wilf Carter
12. Ian Stonebridge
13. Barry Hayles
14. Maurice Tadman
15. Marino Keith
16. Jack Cock
17. Jamie Mackie
18. Gordon Staniforth
19. Carlo Corazzin
20. Fred Binney
21. Adrian Littlejohn
22. Steve Cooper
23. Paul Gallagher
24. Paul McGregor
25. Derek Rickard

Im going to guess that the final 5 will go like this

1. Tommy Tynan
2. Paul Mariner
3. Mickey Evans
4. Nathan Lowndes
5. Freddie Ladapo

No Steve Davey scratch

Guest

Tgwu wrote:: I bet that most of the voters never heard or saw Barrie Jones or Nicky Jennings wonderful players leave the other standing

Trouble with Barrie he was thinking way ahead of the rest of the team, brilliant player but always Nicky for me, I’ve seen nothing since that comes anywhere near him.

Guest

Angry wrote:: Greatest Striker Results So Far
6. Billy Rafferty
7. David Kemp
8. Reuben Reid
9. Dwight Marshall
10. Bradley Wright-Phillips
11. Wilf Carter
12. Ian Stonebridge
13. Barry Hayles
14. Maurice Tadman
15. Marino Keith
16. Jack Cock
17. Jamie Mackie
18. Gordon Staniforth
19. Carlo Corazzin
20. Fred Binney
21. Adrian Littlejohn
22. Steve Cooper
23. Paul Gallagher
24. Paul McGregor
25. Derek Rickard

Im going to guess that the final 5 will go like this

1. Tommy Tynan
2. Paul Mariner
3. Mickey Evans
4. Nathan Lowndes
5. Freddie Ladapo

cant believe i forgot these two worthy strikers :O but sammy black came 4 and S.E.B came 5th.. i still feel my top 3 will be on point though

4. Sammy Black
5. Sylvan Ebanks-Blake

» The Greatest Pilgrims
» Did Pursey say "I am the greatest"
» The greatest Janner
» Pilgrims v MI5
» Argyle's greatest moment

Greatest Pilgrims

cant believe i forgot these two worthy strikers :O but sammy black came 4 and S.E.B came 5th.. i still feel my top 3 will be on point though 4. Sammy Black5. Sylvan Ebanks-Blake

cant believe i forgot these two worthy strikers :O but sammy black came 4 and S.E.B came 5th.. i still feel my top 3 will be on point though

4. Sammy Black
5. Sylvan Ebanks-Blake